Vahn wrote:

 

One recent post I read through was asking for six(!) perks to be removed.

From World at War or MW2, which Perks must stay and which must go? [If you are not sure what these do, please Google them before commenting. I had the descriptions, but the thread was starting to look like a wall of text].

WaW

Perk Set #1

    * Special Grenades X 3
    * Satchel Charge X 2
    * M9A1 Bazooka X 2
    * Bomb Squad
    * Bouncing Betty X 2
    * Bandolier
    * Primary Grenades X 2
    * M2 Flamethrower


Perk Set #2

    * Stopping Power
    * Fireworks
    * Flak Jacket
    * Gas Mask
    * Juggernaut
    * Camouflage
    * Sleight of Hand
    * Shades
    * Double Tap
    * Overkill


Perk Set #3

    * Deep Impact
    * Extreme Conditioning
    * Toss Back
    * Second Chance
    * Martyrdom
    * Fireproof
    * Dead Silence
    * Iron Lungs
    * Reconnaissance

MW2

Perk Set 1

    * Marathon | Marathon Pro
    * Sleight of Hand | Sleight of Hand Pro
    * Scavenger | Scavenger Pro
    * Bling | Bling Pro
    * One Man Army | One Man Army Pro

Perk Slot 2

    * Stopping Power | Stopping Power Pro
    * Lightweight | Lightweight Pro
    * Hardline | Hardline Pro
    * Cold-Blooded | Cold-Blooded Pro
    * Danger Close | Danger Close Pro

Perk Slot 3

    * Commando | Commando Pro
    * Steady Aim | Steady Aim Pro
    * Scrambler | Scrambler Pro
    * Ninja | Ninja Pro
    * SitRep | SitRep Pro
    * Last Stand | Last Stand Pro


Which of these need to go? (A lot of people seem to dislike Commando Pro, but did you also dislike the Bayonet from World at War, which had similar game play?)

I stickied this topic for 5 days and added poll.

David 'Vahn' Vonderhaar

The bayonet was no where near the extent of commando pro.

Vahn wrote:

 

One recent post I read through was asking for six(!) perks to be removed.

From World at War or MW2, which Perks must stay and which must go? [If you are not sure what these do, please Google them before commenting. I had the descriptions, but the thread was starting to look like a wall of text].

WaW

Perk Set #1

    * Special Grenades X 3
    * Satchel Charge X 2
    * M9A1 Bazooka X 2
    * Bomb Squad
    * Bouncing Betty X 2
    * Bandolier
    * Primary Grenades X 2
    * M2 Flamethrower


Perk Set #2

    * Stopping Power
    * Fireworks
    * Flak Jacket
    * Gas Mask
    * Juggernaut
    * Camouflage
    * Sleight of Hand
    * Shades
    * Double Tap
    * Overkill


Perk Set #3

    * Deep Impact
    * Extreme Conditioning
    * Toss Back
    * Second Chance
    * Martyrdom
    * Fireproof
    * Dead Silence
    * Iron Lungs
    * Reconnaissance

MW2

Perk Set 1

    * Marathon | Marathon Pro
    * Sleight of Hand | Sleight of Hand Pro
    * Scavenger | Scavenger Pro
    * Bling | Bling Pro
    * One Man Army | One Man Army Pro

Perk Slot 2

    * Stopping Power | Stopping Power Pro
    * Lightweight | Lightweight Pro
    * Hardline | Hardline Pro
    * Cold-Blooded | Cold-Blooded Pro
    * Danger Close | Danger Close Pro

Perk Slot 3

    * Commando | Commando Pro
    * Steady Aim | Steady Aim Pro
    * Scrambler | Scrambler Pro
    * Ninja | Ninja Pro
    * SitRep | SitRep Pro
    * Last Stand | Last Stand Pro


Which of these need to go? (A lot of people seem to dislike Commando Pro, but did you also dislike the Bayonet from World at War, which had similar game play?)

I stickied this topic for 5 days and added poll.

David 'Vahn' Vonderhaar

Stick with WaW's perk system...you could add a few MW2 perks but stop the pro perk crap and don't make it so noob friendly NO OMA or COMMANDO!

MaTtKs wrote:

 

I'm also one that would love to see damage/health increasing perks (i.e. Stopping Power, Juggernaut, Fireworks) take a hike.

Great minds . . .

II F0XH0UND II wrote:

 

SnazzyPanic wrote:

 

i just deleted a entire essay lol about why u shuldnt remove any perks excepts oma and add juggernaut but tbh no will hear it any way

If you still have it, it is well put, and you think a developer would enjoy reading it I implore you to place it on here. Hell I will read it. You never know, you might bring some insight we all might be missing. Better yet you could bolster previously held or currently held community ideals. Plus this is the first few pages I am sure your post would be read.

nah deleted it, its clear what the community want

I think that MW2 got the perk ideas right. There is enough choice there and even still people only use 5 or 6 of the perks available.
The Pro perks idea is genius and should stay as if you want a perk, instead of just running around with the same set up earning XP and waiting to unlock it at a certain level you can work for it. Although (with the exception of sitrep) they need to be harder to earn IMO.
Also keep Sitrep. Sitrep is so much better than bomb squad but make it perk one again so that it has less competition.